Mesozoic Eucynodonts HOME

MULTITUBERCULATA Cope, 1884



MULTITUBERCULATA, an overview:

PLEASE NOTE: THIS PROJECT IS NOT SCIENTIFIC. IT IS A HOBBY.
"I was looking for information on an old mammal and found this lot. What is this project?"
It's got lots of information on old mammals. For a short bit of background information, see here.

The fifty word version:
Multituberculates were an extinct line of mammals. They were mostly small and lived rodent-like lives. They first appeared in the Jurassic, reached their greatest diversity during the Cretaceous - Paleocene, and then declined. This coincided with the rise of the rodents. The name refers to the multi-cusped teeth.

In their 2001 study, Kielan-Jaworowska and Hurum found that most multis could be referred to two suborders; "Plagiaulacida" and Cimolodonta. An exception is the genus Arginbaatar, which shares characteristics with both groups.

"Plagiaulacida" is paraphyletic; it’s an informal suborder which doesn’t consist of an ancestor and all of its descendants. Its members are the more basal multis. Chronologically, they ranged from perhaps the Middle Jurassic, (unnamed material), until the Lower Cretaceous. It’s further subdivided into three informal groupings: the Allodontid line, the Paulchoffatiid line and the Plagiaulacid line.

Cimolodonta is apparently a natural (monophyletic) suborder. This includes the more derived multis, which have been identified from the Lower Cretaceous to the Eocene. Recognized are the superfamilies Djadochtatheriodea, Taeniolabidoidea, Ptilodontoidea and the Paracimexomys group.

Additionally, there are the families Cimolomylidae, Boffiidae, Eucosmodontidae, Kogainonidae, Microcosmodontidae and the two genera Uzbekbaatar and Viridomys. More precise placement of these types awaits further discoveries and analysis.

With the possible exception of some poorly preserved South American material, multis are only known from the northern hemisphere. A southern grouping, Gondwanatheria, has in the past been referred to the order, though this placement currently has little support.


SUBORDER "PLAGIAULACIDA"

Kielan-Jaworowska and Hurum (2001) divided "Plagiaulacida" into three informal lineages.

1. Allodontid line Both allodontids and paulchoffatiids (below) were amongst the most basal of multituberculate mammals. The Allodontid line contains:
Family: Allodontidae Two genera are known; Ctenacodon and Psalodon. Both come from the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation of North America.
Family: Zofiabaataridae This family contains a single genus, Zofiabaatar, and is also from the Morrison Formation.
The affinities of a further Morrison Formation genus, Glirodon, are unclear, but it’s also within this lineage. 2. Paulchoffatiid line Some remains from the Middle Jurassic of England might belong within this group. Representatives are best known from the Upper Jurassic, (especially from Guimarota, Portugal), though some were still nibbling during the Lower Cretaceous.
Family: Paulchoffatiidae There are a couple of subfamilies:
Subfamily Paulchoffatiinae: Paulchoffatia, Bathmochoffatia, Guimarotodon, Henkelodon, Kielanodon, Meketibolodon, Meketichoffatia, Plesiochoffatia, Pseudobolodon, Xenachoffatia.
Subfamily Kuehneodontinae: Kuehneodon.
Other genera: Galveodon, Sunnyodon, (based on teeth from the Lower Cretaceous of Spain and England respectively). The multis of Guimarota are generally diagnosed on the basis of lower or upper jaws. In only one instance, Kuehneodon, has it been possible to match the two up. Some of the lower jaws probably represent the same genera as some of the upper, so the diversity of paulchoffatiids is very possibly exaggerated. As the site is now a flooded, disused coalmine, further excavations are highly unlikely. However, other locations may yet provide more clarity. Also referable to the paulchoffatiid line are the following:
Family: Hahnodontidae: Presently restricted to the Lower Cretaceous of Morocco: Hahnodon and Denisodon.
Family: Pinheirodontidae: Lower Cretaceous teeth from Iberia and England. The following genera have been established: Pinheirodon, Bernardodon, Ecprepaulax, Gerhardodon, Iberodon and Lavocatia. 3. Plagiaulacid line The members of this line are further derived then is the case with the other two lineages.
Family: Plagiaulacidae: Upper Jurassic (North America) to Lower Cretaceous (Europe and Asia). Plagiaulax, Bolodon, "Ctenacodon" brentbaatar. The "C." requires renaming, whilst material from China has yet to be described, (state of play in 2001).
Family: Albionbaataridae: Upper Jurassic to Lower Cretaceous of Europe and Asia, (China – undescribed, 2001). These were shrew-sized mini multis, with some similarities to the paulchoffis. Albionbaatar, Proalbionbaatar.
Family: Eobaataridae: Eobaatarids display dental similarities with some of the Paracimexomys group, (Cimolodonta). Upper Jurassic to Lower Cretaceous of Europe and Asia, (China – undescribed, 2001). Eobaatar, Loxaulax, Parendotherium, Sinobaatar, and possibly but probably not Monobaatar. Sinobaatar was described after the study by Kielan-Jaworowska and Hurum (2001). It might be based on some of the Chinese material they mentioned as undescribed. The Mongolian word 'baatar' is frequently employed in the nomenclature of multituberculates. This reflects the fact that many of the most complete fossils have been recovered from sites in Mongolia, though this more applies to members of the more derived (Cimolodonta). A couple of further genera possibly fit somewhere within "Plagiaulacida". This has been tentatively proposed for Janumys of the mid Cretaceous. Its contemporary, Ameribaatar, is of uncertain affinities. Both were first described late in 2001.


SUBORDER CIMOLODONTA

Cimolodonta McKenna, 1975 is a suborder within Multituberculata. It appears to represent one ancestor and all of its descendants. For this reason, it's termed monophyletic. Its members are the more derived multis.
The suborder is first known from the Lower Cretaceous, and it extended until the Eocene. So far, cimolodontans are restricted to the northern hemisphere.

Paracimexomys group This informal collection contains both the earliest and most basal cimolodontans. The molars show similarities with the "plagiaulacid" families Plagiaulacidae and Eobaataridae. They're known from the Lower to Upper Cretaceous of North America. A European genus, Barbatodon, was tentatively referred here. However, this was reassigned to Kogaionidae, (below). Paracimexomys, Bryceomys, Dakotamys, and (tentatively) Cimexomys. Cedaromys may or may not belong somewhere near here.
Superfamily: Djadochtatherioidea: Some members of this group are extremely well-preserved. All known remains have been recovered from the Upper Cretaceous of Asia. The previous, tentative inclusion of the North American genus, Pentacosmodon, is doubtful. It's possibly a member of Microcosmodontidae, (below). All Mongolian Upper Cretaceous multis, apart from Buginbaatar, (Cimolomyidae? below), are within this taxon. Family: Sloanbaataridae: Sloanbaatar, Nessovbaatar and perhaps Kamptobaatar.
Family: Djadochtatheriidae: Djadochtatherium, Catopsbaatar, Kryptobaatar, Tombaatar
Other genera within Djadochtatherioidea: Chulsanbaatar, Nemegtbaatar
Placement uncertain: Family: Eucosmodontidae: Eucosmodontids are known largely from teeth. Their placement within Cimiolodonta is not clear. They range from the Upper Cretaceous - Lower Eocene of North America, and the Lower Paleocene - Lower Eocene of Europe. Eucosmodon, Stygimys and perhaps Clemensodon
Family: Microcosmodontidae: Also hard to place are the microcosmodontids. Unsurprisingly, they were micro. They're known from the Upper Cretaceous and Paleocene of North America. Microcosmodon, Pentacosmodon and perhaps Acheronodon
Superfamily: Taeniolabidoidea: This taxon is presently restricted to a single family. Remains are known from the Upper Cretaceous and Paleocene of North America and Asia. This group includes the largest known multis. Taeniolabis is the recordholder. It was something like beaver-big. Family: Taeniolabididae: Taeniolabis, Catopsalis, Lambdopsalis, Prionessus, Sphenopsalis
Placement uncertain: Family: Kogaionidae: Kogaionids are European multis of the Upper Cretaceous - Paleocene. Where known, the skull is reminiscent of the taeniolabidids. However, the snout is longer and the teeth are different. On-going excavations in Romania have been yielding more material. Kogaionon, Barbatodon, Hainina
Superfamily: Ptilodontoidea: Some of these genera boast a great many species, though remains are generally sparse. Ptilodus is amongst the best known, and there's a tendency to depict it as an analogue of a squirrel. Upper Cretaceous remains are known from North America and Europe. (Details about the Europeans would be welcome.) Later representatives, (Paleocene - Eocene), hail from North America, Europe and Asia. Family: Neoplagiaulacidae: Neoplagiaulax, Cernaysia, Ectypodus, Krauseia, Mesodma, Mesodmops, Mimetodon, Parectypodus, Xanclomys, Xyronomys
Family: Ptilodontidae: Ptilodus, Baiotomeus, Kimbetohia, Prochetodon
Family: Cimolodontidae: ?Cimolodon, Anconodon, Liotomus
Placement somewhere within Ptilodontoidea: Of uncertain affinities. I've let it lodge with the neoplagiaulacids, but this is of no significance. Neoliotomus
Placement uncertain: Family: Cimolomyidae: These critters share dental characteristics with various groups of multis, but there are also significant differences. That's why they're hard to place. They're restricted to the Upper Cretaceous of North America and (possibly) Asia. Cimolomys, Meniscoessus (and possibly) Essonodon, Buginbaatar
Family: Boffidae: A monotypic family based on isolated teeth from the Paleocene of Belgium. Boffius
Further genera: More precise placement of these types awaits further discoveries and analysis. Uzbekbaatar and Viridomys


PRIMARY SOURCES

The structure of these directories has now been updated and is largely based upon:

Kielan-Jaworowska Z & Hurum JH, Palaeontology, 2001, 44(3), p.389-429

Kielan-Jaworowska & Hurum, 2001, the abstract

Phylogeny and Systematics of Multituberculate Mammals.

From the abstract of the paper: "We divide the Multituberculata into the paraphyletic suborder 'Plagiaulacida', an apparently monophyletic suborder Cimolodonta, and one family incertae sedis."

I was worried it'd be necessary to buy the aforementioned paper, in order to present a more up-to-date picture of Multituberculata. This would've meant auctioning one of the children. However, a kindly soul took pity and sent a copy.
A new page came on-line and e-bay's lost out. This project appears to be a convincing bash at a representation of Vertebrata. Here's the mammal part:
http://epp.eps.nagoya-u.ac.jp/~seicoro/bio/mammalia.html
Students of Japanese will be able to understand the information better than the rest of us. I'm not yet sure who the author is, but there's a note citing the above paper.

Multituberculata Cope ED, 1884.
Reference: Cope (1884), The Vertebrata of the Tertiary formations of the West. Book I. Report of the United States Geological and Geographical Survey Territories, 3, p.1-1009.