PLEASE NOTE: THIS PROJECT IS NOT SCIENTIFIC. IT IS A HOBBY.
"I was looking for information on an old mammal and found this lot. What is this
project?"
It's got lots of information on old mammals. For a short bit of background information, see
here.
|
This page has been reconstructed in accordance with the following Japanese cladogramme,
which is exceptionally up-to-date, (as of July, 2002):
Mammalia, by ?
http://epp.eps.nagoya-u.ac.jp/~seicoro/bio/mammalia.html
It’s also very large and requires plenty of time to open. The relevant section includes the
note: "Multituberculata after Kielan-Jaworowska and Hurum (2001) Palaeontol 44 389."
The original title of this directory was Taeniolabidoidea. The actual paper has also turned
up. |
A. Eucosmodontidae B.
Microcosmodontidae C. Taeniolabidoidea
| Taxon: Eucosmodontidae Jepsen, 1940
Eucosmodontids formed a taxon of North American (and
apparently also European) multituberculates
which survived the K-T extinctions, at least for a few million years. The group is
poorly known, with the best fossil being an incomplete rostrum of Stygimys,
(part of the skull). There might be a relationship with the Djadochtatherioidea, but
without further finds, this remains unclear. |
| Link:
Mikko Haaramo's Eucosmodontidae
Mikko Haaramo's Eucosmodontidae
Seeing as some generous, (though clearly justified), words about my efforts have appeared
on Mikko Haaramo’s homepage, this cladogramme is self-evidently wonderful. No bribery has
occurred on either side.
Genera: Catopsalis (partly = Stygimys), Cimexomys
(partly = Stygimys), Clemensodon,
Eucosmodon (partly = Stygimys), Kimbetohia
(partly = Clemensodon), Neoplagiaulax (partly = Eucosmodon),
Parectypodus (partly = Stygimys), Stygimys,
other reports
Time-Line:
Paleocene: Eucosmodon, Stygimys
Upper Cretaceous: Clemensodon, Stygimys |
| Genus: Clemensodon Krause
DW, 1992
'Clemens' tooth'
Aka: Kimbetohia Simpson GG, 1936 (partly); ?Mesodma (partly) |
| Species: | Clemensodon megaloba Krause DW, 1992 |
| Aka: | Kimbetohia campi Simpson GG, 1936 (partly) |
| Place: | Lance Formation, Wyoming |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Maastrichtian, Upper Cretaceous |
| Remarks: | A reassessment of a couple of Kimbetohia
teeth, but not the entire species or genus. The type fossil is at Oklahoma. There’s
possibly a second, unnamed species, (see Alroy).
The assignment of this taxon to the family is tentative, (Kielan-Jaworowska & Hurum
2001, p.417). |
| Reference: | Krause (1992), Clemensodon megaloba, a new genus and
species of Multituberculata (Mammalia) from the Upper Cretaceous Type Lance Formation,
Powder River Basin, Wyoming. PaleoBios 14(2), p.1-8. |
| Genus: Eucosmodon Matthew WD &
Granger W, 1921
Aka: Neoplagiaulax (partly)
| Reassigned species: E. gratus Jepsen, 1930 see
?Cimexomys gratus and
Stygimys gratus; E. sparsus Simpson, 1937 and E. jepseni
see Stygimys jepseni; E. kuszmauli see
Stygimys kuszmauli; E. teilhardi Granger &
Simpson, 1929 see Stygimys teilhardi; E.
ultimus Granger & Simpson, 1928 see
Neoliotomus ultimus | |
| Species: | Eucosmodon americanus (Cope ED, 1885) Matthew WD &
Granger W, 1921 |
| Aka: | Neoplagiaulax americanus Cope, 1885 |
| Place: | San Juan Basin, New Mexico & Montana |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
At least some material has been rediagnosed as E. primus, though
seemingly not all. "Descendent of E. primus," (Burkitt JH). This critter
weighed about two rats, 760g. |
| Reference: | Matthew & Granger (1921), New genera of Paleocene mammals. American
Museum Novitates, 13, p.1-7. |
| Species: | ?Eucosmodon kuszmauli |
| Aka: | ?Stygimys kuszmauli |
| Place: | |
| Country: | |
| Age: | |
| Remarks: |
I’m assuming that, in this instance, E. now = S.
This is based partly on the species name, but also on the difficulties of tracking down any
fossils called Euc. kus.. |
| Reference: | |
| Species: | Eucosmodon molestus (Cope ED, 1886) Granger W &
Simpson GG, 1929 |
| Aka: | Neoplagiaulax molestus Cope, 1886 |
| Place: | San Juan Basin, New Mexico |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Torrejonian, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
"Descendent of E. americanus," (Burkitt JH). |
| Reference: | |
| Species: | Eucosmodon primus either Granger W & Simpson GG, 1929
or Sloan RE, 1981 |
| Aka: | E. americanus (at least partly) |
| Place: | Nacimiento Formation, San Juan Basin, New Mexico |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
The holotype was originally identified as E. americanus.
The AMNH collection in New York includes specimens of E. primus, americanus
and E. molestus. John Alroy cites Sloan. |
| Reference: | |
| Genus: Stygimys Sloan RE
& Van Valen L, 1965
'Styx mouse' (Styx = river of hell)
Aka: Catopsalis (partly); Cimexomys (partly); Eucosmodon (partly);
Parectypodus (partly)
Remarks: Some skull material is known, but not much.
Reference: Sloan & Van Valen (1965) Cretaceous mammals from Montana, Science, 148,
p.220-227.
| Reassigned species: S. gratus (Jepsen, 1930) ?see
?Cimexomys gratus and S. kuszmauli | |
| Link:
Peccary Society Notes, Spring 2002
http://www.alfmuseum.org/quest02.pdf
Includes news of a Stygimys tooth, as yet undescribed, from the Paleocene of Utah,
discovered by Kit Clark. It’s a 5mm upper molar. See page 4. |
| Species: | Stygimys jepseni (Simpson GG, 1935) Sloan &
Van Valen, 1965 |
| Aka: | Eucosmodon sparsus Simpson, 1937a; E. jepseni; Parectypodus
jepseni Simpson, 1935d |
| Place: | Montana |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Torrejonian, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
"Descendent of S. kuszmauli," (Burkitt JH). Around 90g. |
| Reference: | Sloan & Van Valen (1965), Cretaceous mammals from Montana.
Science 148 (3367), p.220-227. |
| Species: | Stygimys kuszmauli Sloan RE & Van Valen L,
1965 |
| Aka: | Catopsalis foliatus Cope, 1882; Cimexomys gratus (Jepsen GL, 1930);
Eucosmodon gratus Jepson GL, 1930 (partly); Eucosmodon kuszmauli;
Stygimys gratus |
| Place: | Polecat Bench Fm., Wyoming & ?Judith River Formation, upper
Hell Creek Formation, Lower Tullock Formation all of Montana |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Campanian, ?Upper Cretaceous - Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | The following is based upon my reading of Lofgren,
1995, a study of the geology and specimens from Cretaceous-Paleocene,
McGuire Creek, Montana.
Lofgren had a variety of specimens obtained from over thirty localities near McGuire Creek
(p.79).As originally formulated, the genus of Stygimys contained four species.
S. kuszmauli was newly establshed, but S. gratus, S. jepseni and
S. teilhardi had been set up earlier as members of
Eucosmodon.
However, the holotype of S. gratus (p.81) was accused of being distinct from other
specimens referred to that species, and it opted to become
Cimexomys gratus. This defection left other fossils from the same location,
Mantua Lentil without a valid referral. Equipped, as he was, with a larger sample of
comparable material, Lofgren found no way of distinguishing them from S. kuszmauli
either in terms of size or morphology. He concluded they also represented that species,
which is known to be unusuallly variable (p.86). He also included further fossils of
"S. gratus" from Harbicht Hill.
Lofgren reviewed postcanine teeth of Stygimys
collected from the Bug Creek Anthills (BC), Mantua Lentil (ML) and Harbicht Hill (HH)
localities of Montana (p.82).
Lower p4 premolars
Most specimens have 11 serrations, whereas three from Bug Creek made do with only ten.
All fall within the range of sizes of Bug Creek, although the average size of the Harbicht
Hill contingent is larger. However, there were only eight HH teeth as opposed to 36 BC
ones, so the sampled range there is considerably more restricted. Observed lengths ranged
from 3.82 to 5.46mm.
Sample sizes: BC 37, HH 8, ML 2.
Lower m1 molars
The cusp formula is 6 or 7:5 (buccal to
lingual). Those with seven buccal cusps are in the majority. In terms of size, the
specimens from the three localities couldn't be differentiated. Lengths ran from 3.62 -
4.79mm.
Sample sizes: BC 42, HH 12, ML 1.
Lower m2s
Generally, the cusp formula is 4:2. Three from Bug Creek prefer 5:2. The Harbicht Hill
gang tend to be larger in terms of both width and length, but the differences aren't
major. Lengths range from 2.38 - 3.17mm.
Sample sizes: BC 46, HH 10.
Upper P4 premolars
The cusp formula is variable, and especially so among the Bug Creek contingent; 2-3:7:10:1.
Sizes within both groups are in line with earlier finds from elsewhere both in terms of
length and width. Lengths range from 2.91 - 3.92mm.
Sample sizes: BC 37, HH 3.
Upper M1 molars
On average (p.84), the Harbicht Hill specimens are clearly larger than those from other
samples, but they're within the range of the more numerous Bug Creek collection. The
longest specimen is from Bug Creek. The groups from the separate localities can't be
differentiated by size, and that also means that S. kusmauli and specimens
previously referred to "S. gratus" aren't separable in accordance with the size of
M1. Lengths range from 4.31 - 5.35mm.
Cusp formula is very variable for these teeth; 7-8:7-8:3-8. These figures from Bug Creek
apply to the other two localities as well, although observed variability is less in both
cases. As the numbers involved are also considerably lower, that's not terribly
surprising. Lofgren found not basis for separating two species on these grounds either
(p.85).
Sample sizes: BC 31, HH 2, ML 2.
Upper M2 molars
While the smallest HH molar is longer than the smallest BC one, and the longest HH specimen
beats the BC winner by 0.17mm, the average lengths of both samples aren't far apart;
0.12mm. The cusp formula range varies from 1-3:3:3-4. That means there's less variation
than among M1s but, as there's less molar crown to be customized with cusps, that's also
not exactly surprising.
Smaller sample sizes can give the impression of significant diffrences whereas, should
they be compared with larger ones, such apparent distinctions can melt into the bounds
of internal specific variability (p.86). Looking at only the long and the short of
things can produce a misleading picture, should the middle happen to be unavailable.
Lengths range from 2.33 - 3.05mm.
Sample sizes: BC 28, HH 10.
A Montana summary
As well as assessing the validity of "S. gratus" (bearing in mind that the type
fossil involved scooted off to Cimexomys gratus
and had a patent on the specific name), further details were added to the picture by
specimens from McGuire Creek localities and Harbricht Hill (p.87). This particularly
applied with regards to ranges of variation for details such as numbers of serrations and
cusps.
Holotype
UMVP 1478 is an upper jaw fragment imprisoned in the University of Minnesota,
Minneapolis.
Additional notes
"The Judith River assemblage from Kennedy Coulee,
described by Montellano (1992) contains a tooth of Stygimys kuszmauli (Weil, 1997).
This is the sole tooth known from any Judith River Formation collection that is referable
to Stygimys, so it must be considered to be a possible contaminant from Paleocene
sediments. Because no route of contamination is obvious, however (Weil, in prep.), for the
purpose of this analysis S. kuszmauli has been included in the list from Kennedy
Coulee", (Weil 1999, p.92). Whilst there is evidence for an Upper Cretaceous presence
for this species, it's presently very limited indeed. The material described by Sloan and
Van Valen in 1965 is now considered to be from Paleocene locations.
According to the Sloan interview below, a fair few scraps of jaw are known. This is the
most basal member of the genus, with a weight of 300g. A
number of specimens at Yale and Wyoming, which are clearly assigned to the Upper Cret. A
sample representative boasts the career of E. g., then S. g., followed by
Cim. g. and finally S. k. A colleague used to be known as Ca. f. |
| References: | Sloan & Van Valen (1965), Cretaceous mammals from Montana.
Science 148 (3367), p.220-227. |
| Jepson (1930), Stratigraphy and paleontology of the Paleocene of
northeastern Park County, Wyoming. Proc. Am. Phil. Soc. 69(7), p.463-528. |
| Links:
The Fossil Record of North American Mammals: Evidence for a Paleocene Evolutionary
Radiation, John Alroy
http://www.nceas.ucsb.edu/~alroy/Paleocene.html
A statistical study. "The most important radiation of
therian mammals in their history did occur in the earliest Paleocene."
Interview with Robert Sloan, paleontologist, by Joe Cain, session 6
http://www.ucl.ac.uk/sts/cain/projects/sloan/6.htm
In this interview, Professor Sloan is moved to confess, "I had an
edentulous jaw of Eucosmodon kuszmauli". (A
bit of editorial assistance would be welcome with these transcripts; eg. which Bob and
Malcolm?)
Welcome to Paramount Prosthetics - Our Dental Glossary
http://www.dentureman.com/glossary.cfm?define=29
A dental check-up. Even I managed to work out that edentulous meant without teeth, but I’m
not so inspired when it comes to the curve of Wilson or a hamular notch. Such terms can be
looked up here. A useful resource for surprising your dentist. |
| Species: | Stygimys teilhardi (Granger W & Simpson GG, 1929)
Sloan RE & Van Valen, 1965 |
| Aka: | Eucosmodon teilhardi Granger W & Simpson GG, 1929 |
| Place: | San Juan Basin, New Mexico |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Torrejonian, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | Specimens at AMNH, New York. "Descendant of
S. kuszmauli," (Burkitt JH). |
| Reference: | |
| Species: | Stygimys camptorhiza Johnston PA & Fox RC,
1984 |
| Place: | Rav W-1, Saskatchewan & Montana |
| Country: | Canada & USA |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | The holotype is in the Alberta collection. |
| Reference: | Johnston & Fox (1984), Paleocene and Late Cretaceous
mammals from Saskatchewan, Canada, Palaeontographica Abt. A, 186, p.163-222. |
| Species: | Stygimys cupressus Fox RC, 1989 |
| Place: | Long Fall Horizon, Ravenscrag Formation, Saskatchewan |
| Country: | Canada |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | Lofgren, 1995 contains some information.
The p4 lower premolar has a symmetrical blade, and is
apparently longer than the corresponding tooth of S. kuszmauli (p.87). However,
the four specimens then known still fell within the range of the numerically larger
Montanan Bug Creek collection (34 specimens), albeit consistently towards the upper end
of the scale.
No direct comparison between specimens had been made.
Additional notes
S. cupressus seems to be closely related
with S. camptorhiza, (Weil 1999, p.65). |
| Reference: | Fox (1989), The Wounded Knee local fauna and mammalian evolution
near the Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary, Saskatchewan, Canada. Palaeontographica Abt. A,
208, p.11-59 + 6 plates. |
| Other reports:
Europe
"Distribution. Upper Cretaceous-Lower Eocene of North America; Lower Paleocene-
Lower Eocene of Europe," (Kielan-Jaworowska & Hurum 2001, p.417).
This refers to the range of Eucosmodontidae. I don't know what taxa or locations are
involved. This is a fine opportunity for audience participation.
Alberta, Canada
One tooth (an m1) from a site called Who Nose?, Calgary,
has been referred to cf. Stygimys sp. It's 4,2mm long and has a width of 1,8mm. A
more precise placement would require better evidence, which may turn up. The location is
upper Torrejonian, Paleocene. (Scott 2003, p.751). |
A. Eucosmodontidae B.
Microcosmodontidae C. Taeniolabidoidea
| Taxon: Microcosmodontidae (Holtzman RC & Wolberg DL, 1977) Fox
RC, 1999
Would it surprise anyone to know that microcosmodontids were rather small? They also had
a "large lower incisor with a restricted enamel band,
(Kielan-Jaworowska & Hurum 2001, p.417).
This grouping has also be seen as Microcosmodontinae Holtzman & Wolberg, 1977, within
Eucosmodontidae. However, "Microcosmodontidae (new rank assigned by Fox to the
subfamily Microcosmodontinae)," (Kielan-Jaworowska & Hurum, 2001).
Referring specifically to Microcosmodontinae, Scott, 2003 (p.753) reports: "m1s of this
group are characterized generally by low cusp number, stout, robust cusps, anteriorly
converging cusp rows, and the presence of a sigmoid notch (Krause, 1977; Weil, 1998)."
'm1' is the first lower molar.
With regard to Microcosmodontinae: "Their geographic range is limited: aside from a
questionably referred isolated incisor from the Goler Formation of California (McKenna et
al., 1987) and a possibly misidentified isolated incisor from England (Sloan, 1981),
microcosmodontines are known only from the northern portion of North America's Western
Interior", (Weil 1999, p.31-32).
References: Holtzman & Wolberg (1977), The Microcosmodontinae and Microcosmodon woodi
, new multituberculate taxa (Mammalia) from the Late Paleocene of North America. Sci.
Publi. of the Sci. Museum of Minnesota, New Series, r, p.1-13.
Fox (1999), The monophyly of the Taeniolabidoidea (Mammalia: Multituberculata), p.26 in
Leanza (ed.). Abstracts, VII International Symposium on Mesozoic Terrestrial Ecosystems,
Buenos Aires, p.64.
Genera: Acheronodon,
Microcosmodon, Pentacosmodon,
other reports
Time-Line:
Paleocene: Acheronodon, Microcosmodon
Upper Cretaceous: Pentacosmodon |
| Genus: Acheronodon
Archibald JD, 1982
Remarks: A lower molar (m1) is among the Who Nose? fauna
from Calgary, Alberta. It's most similar to the m1s of this genus, which is basal, (Scott
2003, p.753). The locality is Torrejonian, Paleocene. |
| Species: | Acheronodon garbani Archibald JD, 1982 |
| Place: | Tullock Formation, Montana & ?Porcupine Hills, Alberta |
| Country: | USA & ?Canada |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
The holotype (and only known specimen of this species) was found in Montana. It's an
isolated and damaged lower premolar, (p4). This may
belong in the same genus as Microcosmodon, but the lack of specimens and state of
preservation make this unclear.
A separate species may be represented at Porcupine Hills (Tiffanian). |
| Reference: | Archibald (1982), A study of Mammalia and geology across the
Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary in Garfield County, Montana. University of California
Publications in Geological Sciences 122, p.1-286. |
| Genus: Microcosmodon
Jepsen GL, 1930 |
| Species: | Microcosmodon arcuatus Johnston PA & Fox RC,
1984 |
| Place: | Rav W-1 Horizon, Saskatchewan |
| Country: | Canada |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
The type fossil, collected in 1975, is studying at Alberta. The
size of a well fed mouse, 30g.
Weil, 1999 (p.19) states the referral of this species to the genus is questionable:
"until more is known about it." However, on page 22 she states it: "almost
certainly belongs in Microcosmodon, although its incompleteness with regard to the
matrix in this study results in a polytomy at Microcosmodontinae (node A, Figure 1a)." |
| Reference: | Johnston & Fox (1984), Paleocene and Late Cretaceous mammals
from Saskatchewan, Canada. Palaeontographica Abt. A: Paläozool., Stratigr. 186, p.163-222.
|
| Species: | Microcosmodon conus Jepsen GL, 1930 |
| Place: | Polecat Bench Fm., Wyoming & Saskatchewan |
| Country: | USA & Canada |
| Age: | Tiffanian, Middle-Upper Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
The holotype was found in Wyoming and lives at the Peabody with some colleagues. Some
further specimens work in Wyoming University. A diminutive 15g animal.
Weil, 1999 (p.20): "The majority-rule consensus tree (Figure 1b) shows that the two
youngest species, M. conus and M. rosei, may be sister
taxa, and that the new species described below,
M. harleyi, may be more closely related to them than to M. arcuatus." |
| Reference: | Stratigraphy and paleontology of the Paleocene of northeastern
Park County, Wyoming. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 83 (2), p.463-528. |
| Species: | Microcosmodon harleyi Weil A, 1999 |
| Place: | Tullock Formation, Montana |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
The following is largely based upon my reading of Weil, 1999.
"Diagnosis - A species of Microcosmodon distinguished from other members of the
genus by the presence of strong lateral ridges on the p4 in combination with parallel rather
than posteriorly divergent cusp rows on the m1", (p.23).
Lower premolars, (p4s), play a crucial role in the
diagnosis of North American multis. These are blade-like teeth with serrations, which were
fine for slicing up salad. In the case of this creature, there was a relatively low number
of them; six. Some of its near relatives had to make do with five serrations. A small
hollow at the base of the front of the tooth infers it was partnered by a p3, (p.24).
There are two roots, of which the front one was the larger.
The m1 lower molars have two rows of cusps; five at the front
and four to the rear. The m2s boast of three and two. Some tentatively referred upper
molars (M1s) have three lines of cusps - 4-5+:5:3-?, (p.26).
The type fossil, UCMP 144449, is an inmate of the University of California Museum of
Paleontology. This is a lower, right premolar (p4). It enjoys the company of further p4s,
lower molars and upper premolars. Some upper molars have been tentatively referred. These
fossils have been recovered from several locations within the Garbani channel facies of
Montana. The species name honours Mr Harley Garbani, who spent years collecting in the
area.
"The presence of the new species suggests that microcosmodontine species richness in
the Western Interior was as high at the beginning of the Paleocene as at its end,"
(Weil, 1998). A 20 grammer. I’ll resist announcing a new subspecies named davidsoni, though
it’s tempting. The abstract of this article (A new species of Microcosmodon
(Mammalia: Multituberculata) from the Paleocene Tullock Formation of Montana, and an
argument for the Microcosmodontinae) is linked to the entry for Pentacosmodon,
below. Anne Weil's 1999 paper contains the description.
|
| Reference: | Weil (1999), Multituberculate phylogeny and mammalian
biogeography in the Late Cretaceous and earliest Paleocene Western Interior of North
America, Ph.D. Dissertation, University of California, Berkeley, p.1-243. |
| Species: | Microcosmodon rosei Krause DW, 1980 |
| Place: | Willwood Formation, Wyoming |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Clarforkian, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | A fairly standard mouse-sized 25g+. |
| Reference: | Krause (1980), Multituberculates from the Clarkforkian
land-mammal Age, Late Paleocene-Early Eocene, of western North America. Journal of
Paleontology, 54 (6), p.1163-1183. |
| Species: | "Microcosmodon woodi" Holtzman RC & Wolberg DL, 1977 |
| Aka: | eucosmodontid woodi Weil, 1998 |
| Place: | Wyoming, Montana & North Dakota & Alberta |
| Country: | USA & Canada |
| Age: | Tiffanian, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
Weil A (1998) found that this material "does not belong to this genus or
subfamily." The abstract is below, linked to Pentacosmodon.
Presently known from the lower teeth are a premolar (p4)
and an incisor (i1). The p4 isn't relatively small or
blessed with a high and rounded crown, and is therefore unlike those of
microcosmodontinids, (Weil 1999, p.22). A relationship with Stygimys kuzsmauli is
possible, (eg. p.39). |
| Reference: | Holtzman & Wolberg (1977), The Microsmodontinae and
Microcosmodon woodi, new Multituberculata taxa (Mammalia) from the Late Paleocene of
North America. Sci. Publ. of the Sci. Mus. of Minnesota, 4(1), p.1-13. |
| Genus: Pentacosmodon
Jepsen GL, 1940 |
| Species: | Pentacosmodon pronus Jepsen, 1940 |
| Place: | Wyoming & Porcupine Hills Formation, Bow River, Alberta |
| Country: | USA & Canada |
| Age: | Tiffanian, Upper Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
P. pronus was described from a nearly complete right
mandible, found in the Tiffanian Polecat Bench assemblage of Wyoming with M.
[icrocosmodon] conus, and it possessed a similar, relatively small p4", (Weil
1999, p.6).
There may be a separate species from Porcupine Hills. |
| Reference: | Jepsen (1940), Paleocene faunas of the Polecat Bench Formation,
Park County, Wyoming. Proc. of the Am. Philos. Soc., 83, p.217-338. |
| Other reports:
Canada, Alberta
Cochrane 2, Paskapoo Formation, earliest Tiffanian, Paleocene.
Scott et al, 2002, reports two presently undescribed microcosmodontids are known from this
site. They are being worked on by Fox RC. This is mentioned on page 691, (see
Bibliography for details of the paper). |
A. Eucosmodontidae B.
Microcosmodontidae C. Taeniolabidoidea
| Taxon: Taeniolabidoidea (Sloan RE & Van Valen L, 1965)
McKenna & Bell, 1997, Fox, 1999
Taxon: Taeniolabididae Granger W & Simpson GG, 1929
Reference: Granger & Simpson (1929), A revision of the Tertiary Multituberculata.
Bulletin of the Am. Museum of Nat. Hist., 56, p.601-676.
Taeniolabidoidea is a clade of derived
multituberculates from the northern hemisphere. It was initially established as a
suborder, before being assigned the rank of a superfamily by McKenna & Bell, 1997, (see
Kielan-Jaworowska & Hurum (2001) p.391-392). It's now strictly limited to the family
Taeniolabididae, (with thanks to Dr Kielan-Jaworowska). Some of the fossils are well
preserved. Catopsalis is known from the Upper Cretaceous of Canada, though the
family's best represented from Paleocene strata.
Derived characteristics of the taxon,
apomorphis, include: "snout short and wide with
anterior part of zygomatic arches directed transversely, resulting in a square-like shape of
the skull (shared with Kogaionidae); frontals small,
pointed posteriorly, almost or completely excluded from the
orbital rim," (Kielan-Jaworowska & Hurum 2001, p.417).
Some of these animals were macho-multis. However, and in my unqualified opinion, some of
the calculation methods which generate the body mass estimates do appear to overstate
things in these cases. Taeniolabis taoensis is the largest known multi, but a body
mass of 102kg seems unlikely. It was about beaver-size and presumably about beaver-heavy,
(with thanks to
Sevilleta LTER, the University of New Mexico). That would mean no more than 30 kilos.
Where relevant, I shall employ the following highly specialized, scientific terms of my own
concoction; heavyweight, super-heavyweight, sumo-heavyweight and sumo-super-heavyweight.
|
| Links:
Mikko Haaramo's Taeniolabididae
Mikko Haaramo's Taeniolabididae
Martin Jehle, Multituberculates: Heyday of the longest lived mammalian order
http://www.paleocene-mammals.de/multis.htm
A comprehensible overview of multis. Members of Taeniolabididae feature strongly.
Genera: Bubodens, Catopsalis,
Lambdopsalis, Oracodon (= Meniscoessus),
Polymastodon (= Catopsalis / Taeniolabis),
Prionessus, Sphenopsalis,
Taeniolabis, other reports
Time-Line:
Paleocene: Catopsalis, Lambdopsalis, Prionessus, Sphenopsalis,
Taeniolabis
Upper Cretaceous: Bubodens |
| Genus: Bubodens (awaiting
publication) |
| Species: | Bubodens magnus |
| Place: | South Dakota |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Upper Cretaceous |
| Remarks: | The only lower
molar known is an m1. In Mesozoic mammalian
terms, this is exceptionally large; length ca. 13mm, width 6mm, (Clemens et al, 2003).
This also receives a brief mention in Weil, 2005 p.116). Remains are restricted to just a
single tooth. However, this must've been a mega-multi. According to the suggested
comparison it was: "at least as large as
R.[epenomamus] robustus and may have been as large as R. giganticus".
That range is between 0.5 - 1m.
As this material hasn't yet been formally described, this entry's placement within this
section is provisional. |
| Reference: | |
| Link:
Anne Weil, Curriculum Vitae -January 2003
http://www.baa.duke.edu/weillab/Webvita.pdf
The title of the planned publication appears on page 4 -Publications in Process. Weil A
& Clemens WA (in review) Bubodens magnus (Mammalia: Multituberculata) from the
Late Cretaceous of South Dakota and implications for diversification of Taeniolabididae.
Acta Palaeontologica Polonica. |
| Genus: Catopsalis Cope ED,
1882
Aka: Polymastodon sp.
Remarks: The Mongolian Connection?
Page 508 of Kielan-Jaworowska et al, 2005 states this genus is also known from the Paleocene
of Mongolia, and they give a reference for Matthew, Granger & Simpson, 1928. I find
this odd and wonder whether there's a connection with
Sphenopsalis, a genus of the same time, place and that authorship.
I've checked Matthew et al thoroughly and conclude Sphenopsalis was probably the
genus meant, as K-J et al specify Prionessus as present.
Lofgren, 1995
Lofgren was writing about fossils from a number of localities at and near McGuire Creek,
Montana (p.89). At the time the genus of Catopsalis was known to be
paraphyletic. This was at least in part due to the
inclusion of C. catopsaloides from Mongolia, a species which later deserted to
become Catopsbaatar. At least two natural
species are known to have been lurking in the Paleocene of Montana; C. joyneri
and C. alexanderi. However, they'd never been found together at the same locality.
That could be due to insufficient sample sizes, different ages or perhaps some other
factor; eg. dofferent habitat preferences.
Members of the genus seem to have put on weight over the generations. C. joyneri
is a comparative smalling, the possibly somewhat later C. alexanderi is larger, and
the yet later C. foliatus could've qualified for some class or other of
multituberculate sumo wrestler, should multis
have pursued such interests.
Reference (for the genus): Cope (1882), A second genus of Eocene Plagiaulacidae, The
American Naturalis, vol 16, p.416-417.
| Reassigned species: C. catopsaloides see
Catopsbaatar catopsaloides; C. foliatus Cope, 1882 (partly)
see Stygimys kuszmauli; C. johnstoni
Fox, 1989 see C. foliatus; C. pollux Cope, 1882 see
Taeniolabis taoensis; C. utahensis Gazin,
1939 see C. fissidens | |
| Species: | Catopsalis foliatus Cope ED, 1882 |
| Aka: | C. johnstoni Fox RC, 1989; Polymastodon foliatus
Cope, 1884 |
| Place: | San Juan Basin, New Mexico, Montana & Ravenscrag Formation |
| Country: | USA & Canada |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | According to Lofgren, 1995, this was a relatively
large species for the genus.
"Descendant of C. joyneri," (Burkitt JH).
C. johnstoni, from Saskatchewan, is also at Alberta. Heavyweight. |
| References: | Cope (1882), A second genus of Eocene Plagiaulacidae, The
American Naturalist, 16, p.416-417. |
| Fox (1989), The Wounded Knee local fauna and mammalian evolution
near the Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary, Saskatchewan, Canada. Palaeontogr. Abt. A:
Paläozool., Stratigr. 208, p.11-59 + 6 plates. |
| Species: | Catopsalis fissidens Cope ED, 1884 |
| Aka: | C. utahensis Gazin CL, 1939; Polymastodon fissidens
Cope, 1884 |
| Place: | San Juan Basin, New Mexico, Utah &
?Wyoming |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Torrejonian, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
"Descendant of C. utahensis," (Burkitt JH), which
now seems improbable seeing as their synonyms. The University of Wyoming boasts a possible
specimen. Super-heavyweight. |
| References: | Cope (1884), A second addition to the knowledge of the
Puerco Epoch, American Philosophical Society Proceedings, vol 37, p.309-324. |
| Gazin (1939), A further contribution to the Dragon Paleocene
fauna of central Utah. J. Wash. Acad. Sci. 29, p.273-286, 10 figs. |
| Species: | Catopsalis calgariensis Russell LS, 1926 |
| Place: | Paskapoo Formation, Alberta &
Wyoming |
| Country: | Canada & USA |
| Age: | Torrejonian? - Tiffanian?, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | The following is based upon my reading of
Simpson, 1927b, which isn't the original description.
The first mammal fossils from the Paskapoo Formation
were introduced to the Paleontological Society of America in good time to experience World
War One (p.1). Their public debut occurred on New Year's Day in 1914. Barnum Brown and WD
Matthew let it be known that they obtained some teeth and jaws and, of wider significance,
these fossils helped establish the age of the Formation. A list of tentative
identifications was compiled by Matthew, and there were obvious overlaps with the Lancian
mammals from Wyoming. These similarities strongly suggested an Upper Cretaceous age
because...
Whoops
It later transpired that specimens had got muddled up. Those faunal overlaps were caused by
intruders collected from Hell Creek in Montana (p.9). The error was spotted when the
catalogue numbers were rechecked, and that wasn't until Simpson was preparing this 1927
paper for publication. None of the Paskapoo specimens were known from the Upper Cretaceous.
These, and subsequent mammals, claimed to be Paleocene, and geologists came to agree with
them. They'd been collected by Brown in 1910 when he was hunting dinos along the Red Deer
River. At one point he tripped over the rubble left by an impressive landslide. About a
hundred metres of canyon wall had fallen from around 50 metres higher (p.1), and Brown
saw fossils in an isolated block of stone. It contained remains from at least seven
taxa.
A glimpse of Catopsalis calgariensis
This new species was the sole multi among them, and it was described by Russell. That work
hadn't appeared when Simpson was writing his summary of the fauna, but he was allowed a
sneak preview (p.2). He agreed with Russell's conclusions and added a new photo of an m2
molar. As I've not seen the description, my information on
the species is presently less than extensive.
In comparison to C. foliatus the holotype (also an m2) is bigger, more robustly built
and the final cusp of the buccal row is reduced. The
proportions also differ, as this crown is relatively wider. The molar is 9.0mm long and 8.5
wide. The type of C. foliatus (the corresponding tooth) measures 6.6 by 5.7.
Holotype
The holotype, collected in 1924, is in the Alberta collection. Further material is in the
Wyoming collection. Sumo-heavyweight.
Additional note
"Descendant of C. fissidens", (John H Burkitt). |
| Reference: | Russell (1926), A new species of the genus Catopsalis Cope from
the Paskapoo formation of Alberta, American Journal of Science, vol 12, p.230-234. |
| Species: | Catopsalis joyneri Sloan RE & Van Valen L, 1965
|
| Place: | Bug Creek Anthills, Montana & Wyoming & Saskatchewan |
| Country: | USA & Canada |
| Age: | Upper Cretaceous? - Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | Lofgren, 1995 provides some information starting
on page 90. His research concerns
McGuire Creek, Montana.
The type fossil, along with many other colleagues, used to revel in the Bug Creek Anthills
of Montana during the Puercan part of the Paleocene. The species may also have frequented
Saskatchewan. McGuire Creek localities added more numbers to the supply, and Lofgren
provided measurements from both there and the larger Bug Creek Anthills collection.
I'm sticking to legnths and combining information from both presented tables.
Postcanines
Uppers: P4 (7 specimens) 2.98-3.47mm; M1 (11 sp.) 7.56-8.65mm; M2 (5 measurable sp.)
5.08-5.80mm.
Lowers: m1 (14 sp.) 5.71-7.17cm; m2 (4 sp.) 5.74-6.10mm.
The McGuire Creek P4 has heavy wear and its cusp formula is unclear: 1:5?:?
(buccal to lingual, p.91).
The solitary buccal cusp is small, and sits upon a cingulum
to the rear of the crown. What remains of the middle row is similar to C. alexanderi
other than for being smaller. No trace of lingual cusps remains.
An upper M2 molar is moderately worn, and its cusps number
1:3:3. The buccal cusp is like a ridge towards the front of the tooth. The middle row
cusps increase in size along the line. Lingual cusps are close to one another in terms of
size.
A lower m1 is described as being similar to previously collected Bug Creek Anthill
speciemens. As little more was said beyond its cusp formula, 5:4, little scope is
available for eulogising it further.
Holotype
UMVP 1494 is a right maxilla with complete palate now
being educated at the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis.
Additional notes
One tooth studies at Wyoming and is Puercan. The Montana
material is now thought to be Paleocene, though the Canadian site, (Cypress Hill region),
is considered Upper Cretaceous.
In their 2000 study of the cranium of Kryptobaatar, (see Bibliography), Wible and
Rougier constantly use inverted commas for the generic name with this species;
"Catopsalis" joyneri. I couldn't find an explanation. I presume it means
this species may belong to a different genus. |
| Reference: | Sloan & Van Valen (1965), Cretaceous mammals from Montana.
Science, 148, p.220-227. |
| Species: | Catopsalis alexanderi Middleton MD, 1982 |
| Place: | Littleton Local Fauna, Colorado,
Montana & Wyoming |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | lower Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | Eberle, 2003 (p.149-150) includes a description
of a specimen from South Table Mountain, Colorado. It's a right lower
molar, (m2). Although a bit longer, it's otherwise very
similar to material described in 1982. To get some idea of relative size between the
various species, it's smaller than the corresponding teeth from C. calgariensis and
C. fissidens, but larger than C. joyneri.
The main contrast to C. foliatus is also a matter of smaller size, although only one
m2 is known for that species. Rather than length, the distinguishing dimension is width.
C. alexanderi is significantly narrower. The South Table Mountain is a bit larger
than the Littleton fossils, but the difference isn't sufficient to justify a separate
taxon.
The stomach treatment
The new fossil has lost most of its enamel, so the length/width of 7.5 and 5.15mm are
somewhat minimalised. This was probably caused by a crocodile. Should you feel like
testing this hypothesis, encourage your croc to swallow some mammalian teeth, and wait for
them to come out the other end. This probably won't make much difference to the shape, but
the gastric juices will eradicate most of the enamel. Several other mammal molars from
the location evidentially underwent a similar treatment.
Holotype
The holotype, UCM 34979, is part of a right dentary in
the collection of the University of Colorado Museum in Boulder. It includes a
premolar and two molars, (p4-m2).
Lofgren, 1995 provides information on further specimens from
McGuire Creek, Montana.
He reports this as being a middling-sized representative of the genus (p.91), and appears
to be middling in terms of time as well. Members of the species have been arrested at
further Puercan localities including the Polecat Bench Formation (Wyoming), and Montana's
Upper Hell Creek and lower Tullock Formations.
Lofgren identified three specimens from McGuire Creek and Harbicht Hill. Their sizes
are close to those recorded earlier by Middleton; lengths (upper): M1 9.15mm, M2 6.87;
(lower): m2 about 6.76mm. These teeth are larger than those of another former resident of
Montana, C. joyneri. These two species have never been found to share the same
locality.
The upper M1 is unworn but broken at the front on the buccal
side (p.92). Only five cusps have survived there. As its proportions are similar to
C. joyneri, it's likely there were originally seven or more. Both other rows
contain eight cusps. The lingual row commences about 10%
of the crown length from the front margin.
An M2 molar was recovered from Harbicht Hill. Its size and cusp formula of 1:3:3
(buccal to lingual) correspond with C. alexanderi
McGuire Creek also yielded a lower molar and some incisors. The m2 has been modestly
worn but part of its rear is missing. Its cusp formula is 3:2 (or more). The lower
incisors aren't formally assigned to a species but, on the grounds of size, they are
probably from this one.
Additional notes
Some material of this species was previously assigned to C. foliatus and C.
joyneri. Three specimens are listed on the AMNH database, New York with others at the
Peabody. This was a heavyweight multi. |
| Reference: | Middleton (1982), A new species and additional material of
Catopsalis (Mammalia, Multituberculata) from the western interior of North America.
Journal of Paleontology, 56 (5), p.1197-1206. |
| Species: | Catopsalis collariensis |
| Place: | Red Deer River |
| Country: | Canada |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
The type fossil is listed as an employee at the AMNH, New York. |
| Reference: | |
| Species: | Catopsalis waddleae Buckley GA, 1995 |
| Place: | Simpson Quarry, Montana |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | Sumo-heavyweight. |
| Reference: | |
| Genus: Lambdopsalis
Chow M & Qi T, 1978 |
| Species: | Lambdopsalis bulla Chow & Qi, 1978 |
| Place: | Nomogen, Bayan Ulan & Subeng |
| Country: | China |
| Age: | Upper Paleocene |
| Remarks: |
This genus of probable burrowers provides the first direct
evidence of mammal fur. (This became out of date as of May 2002. Eomaia is now the
record-holder, from the Lower Cretaceous of China.) Hair is highly unlikely to fossilize.
There are indications that it first appeared on non-mammalian therapsids, way back in the
Triassic, or even earlier. This is inferred from small hollows on the bone of the snout,
which may have and probably did provide space for concentrations of nerves and blood
vessels. It’s a feature also known from cats. (If you have one at home, please don’t cut it
open to check). This adaptation allows Felix to use its whiskers, (specialized hairs), as
effective sensory organs.
However, exceptional fossils from China do actually include mammal fur, some of which is
from Lambdopsalis. These are coprolites, fossilized crap, which contain the
undigested leftovers excreted by carnivores. (With thanks to Martin Jehle. See the link at
the head of this section.)
The Peabody has a couple of cast L. specimens, including one of the type fossil.
According to their database, Wyoming University has a cast shell assigned to the order
Chelonia, (aka tortoises and turtles), UW-44093. I realize some strict interpretations
don’t classify multis as mammals, but this is the first
time I’ve found one referred to as a turtle. I can't find any other support for this novel
use of the word Lambdopsalis.
News from Subeng
Missiaen & Smith, 2008 reports the presence of over a hundred teeth for this species from
the Subeng fauna (p.359). That qualifies it as relatively common; a situation reflected
in other local faunas. However, apart from adding a new locality to the inventory, this
collection added not a lot to what was already known. |
| Reference: | Chow & Qi (1978), Paleocene mammalian fossils from Nomogen
Formation of Inner Mongolia. Vertebrata PalAsiatica 16(2), p.77-85. |
| Links:
Contributions to Geology 24(1), 1986
http://home.gg.uwyo.edu/publicationsandservices/CG/CGAbstract.asp?ArticleID=353&type=RI
At one time, the validity of this genus was questioned. This abstract by Miao Desui, serves
to preserve the reputation and status of Chinese multis. "Cladistic analysis clearly
documents phylogenetic unity of the Asian Tertiary
multituberculates Prionessus, Sphenopsalis, and
Lambdopsalis."
Osi ürülékek - szormentén
http://www.sulinet.hu/eletestudomany/archiv/1997/9736/tudvil/urulek/urulek.html
A fascinating article in Hungarian. I wonder what it says? However, it does include some
photos of 60 million year old droppings and hair.
Berliner Zeitung, 5.3.1997
http://www.berlinonline.de/wissen/berliner_zeitung/archiv/1997/0305/none/0152/
Älteste Säugetierhaare entdeckt, (German). 'Oldest mammal hair discovered'.
University of Wyoming, Jason A Lillegraven
http://home.gg.uwyo.edu/people/faculty/pubsArticles.asp?PersonID=136
Included is a link to the on-line Wyoming catalogue, featuring the oddly named turtle.
|
| Genus: Prionessus Matthew WD
& Granger W, 1925 |
| Species: | Prionessus lucifer Matthew WD & Granger W,
1925 |
| Place: | Gashato, Naran & Nomogen, Bayan Ulan, & Subeng |
| Country: | Mongolia & China |
| Age: | Upper Paleocene |
| Remarks: | The following is based upon my reading of Matthew,
Granger and Simpson, 1928, which isn't the original description.
Prionessus was originally founded on an edentulous
lower jaw harvested in 1923 (p.1). Further specimens were harvested four years later, and
these provided the material for the 1928 paper. Among the expanded collection were: a
lower jaw fragment with both molars, part of an upper jaw
with molars, and isolated and partial teeth. These came from relatively small multis.
Lower molars
The available m1 is broken and the m2 worn. Mammals can be careless with their teeth, and
take pleasure in using them. As is usual for later multis, the first molar is both longer
and narrower than the second. It has two rows of cusps but the numbers are uncertain;
perhaps five buccal and four
lingual cusps. The authors term the crown of m2 subtriangular, and the cusp rows boast
of three and two members, (buccal and lingual respectively). These are large, squarish
and rather featureless cusps. The final pair of the external trio share parts of their
base with each other.
Uppers
Excepting for a single alveolus, the fragment of
maxilla is broken off in front of the molars.
Comparisons with other multis indicated this hole probably played host to a
premolar. Upper molars had three cusp rows with the
likely formula of 6:7:5 for the M1. While the buccal and middle rows were of similar
lengths, the latter was wider. The lingual line thins as it progresses forwards, and
peters out before reaching the front of the crown. As with the lowers, the cusps show no
interest in ornamentations such as furrows or ridges. This contrasts with the approach of
many of their North American relatives from the Cretaceous and Paleocene, although wear
might be partly to blame.
As with its lower counterpart, M2 also has a subtriangular shape. Its maximum width and
length are much the same as each other. In contrast to the lower, the shortest cusp row
is the lingual one (p.2), and the formula is probably
1:3:3.
Relationships
The authors suggested affinities with Catopsalis,
Meniscoessus and
Taeniolabis rather than with
ptilodontids (p.4). They accepted the possibility
of a particularly close relationship with Catopsalis.
Subeng
Missiaen & Smith, 2008 reports on the presence of the genus in the Subeng fauna. A
fragmentary upper molar was arrested there. It wasn't referred to a species. There's
the possibility that material already collected from elsewhere involves two species, with
the recognisable distinction being the number of roots of the p4 premolar. That's a
topic that a lone right molar is ill-equipped to discuss. |
| Reference: | Matthew & Granger (1925), Fauna and correlation of the
Gashato Formation of Mongolia. Am. Museum Novitates, 189, p.1-12. |
| Genus: Sphenopsalis
Matthew WD , Granger W & Simpson GG, 1928
'wedge scissors'
Remarks: The generic name refers to the shearing cusps of the molars, and also points to
possible allegiances with Catopsalis from America. |
| Species: | Sphenopsalis nobilis Matthew WD, Granger W &
Simpson GG, 1928 |
| Place: | Gashato & Nomogen |
| Country: | Mongolia & China |
| Age: | Upper Paleocene |
| Remarks: | The following is based on my reading of Matthew
et al, 1928.
This is a meaty multi approaching the dimensions of
Taeniolabis. That surely qualifies it as Sumo-super-heavyweight in the ever so
scientific jargon of this section. The information Matthew and Co had available was very
limited, and I haven't heard of any significant improvements since. They had one reasonably
complete tooth and a few bits from others.
What a whopper!
The best specimen is an upper molar (M2). It's 11mm wide and 14 long (p.2). As
Taeniolabis reached something like the size of a beaver, that comparison shouldn't
be all too inaccurate for this beast (I hope). Multi upper molars typically have three
rows of cusps and, in this case, the rows from buccal to
lingual contain one, two and four cusps respectively.
These cusps bear high, 'narrow and sharp crests', (as expressed on p.4), which is atypical
for multis. This adaptation will be mentioned below, so you won't be able to sensibly
claim you weren't informed.
Other teeth
A number of isolated fragments probably come from the same genus (p.3). There's the front
of a lower molar (m1). The complete crown would've been
seven or eight millimetres across. That might be a bit small for a precise match, but it's
not all that far from expectations. Present are two rows of simple cusps devoid of fussy
elaborations such as ridges or grooves, as also applies for the uppers. They possess the
sharp crests too. Even if this isn't from the same species, the structure is
complementary enough to pass muster as at least very close.
A further partial m1 is broadly similar in architecture, as far as they're comparable. In
this case, the width at the front of the crown is 10.6mm, and that matches specimens of
Taeniolabis taoensis (p.4).
Things to do with sharp crests
Cutting. Generally, multi molars are crushers and grinders. Food items were sliced by
the specialised premolars, although not in
basal representatives. Molars were responsible for
milling. In this case, the crests fit better with slicing duties. Teeth are the hardest
parts of a mammalian body, but they're remarkably plastic across the generations, and
adaptations tend to train them for optimum performance in attacking the preferred food.
These blades seem to be aids for a particular diet.
What that may have been will probably never be known, but it was doubtlessly yummy.
Affinities
The authors tentatively accepted a possible relationship between Sphenopsalis and
Catopsalis and Taeniolabis. With reference to the
shearing specialisations of the molars: "The adaptive type is very different from that
of Taeniolabis, with its broad crushing teeth, but Catopsalis is somewhat
intermediate in adaptation." Nevertheless, they identified similarities between T.
and what was known of S.. They also noted "the inadequacy of the known
material" for confidence concerning relationships.
Holotype
AMNH 21736 is a left upper molar, which resides in New York. The origins of the specific
name are doubtlessly interesting, but they're not mentioned in the paper. |
| Reference: | Matthew et al (1928), Paleocene multituberculates from Mongolia. Am.
Museum Novitates, 331, p.1-4. |
| Genus: Taeniolabis Cope
ED, 1882a
Aka: Catopsalis (partly); Polymastodon Cope, 1882b (partly)
Remarks: Further information on this genus is contained in Martin Jehle’s article, linked
at the top of this section.
Reference: Cope (1882), Mammalia in the Laramie Formation. American Naturalist, 16,
p.830-831.
| Reassigned species: T. attetuatus see T. taoensis; T.
scalper Cope, 1884 see T. taoensis; T. sulcatus Cope, 1882 see
T. taoensis; T. teiserialis Granger & Simpson, 1929 see T.
taoensis | |
| Species: | Taeniolabis taoensis (Cope ED, 1882) |
| Aka: | Catopsalis pollux Cope, 1882b; Polymastodon attenuatus
Cope, 1885; P. latimolis Cope, 1885; P. selenodus Osborn HF & Earle C, 1895;
P. taoensis Cope, 1882; T. attetuatus; T. scalper Cope 1884;
T. sulcatus Cope 1882a; T. triserialis Granger & Simpson, 1929 |
| Place: | Nacimiento Formation, New Mexico,
Colorado, Utah,
Wyoming & Ravenscrag Formation, Saskatchewan |
| Country: | USA & Canada |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | The following is based on my reading of Broom,
1914.
Polymastodon was erected for a fragmentary skull and bits of lower jaw, and it
turned out to be co-generic with Taeniolabis. A very helpful near complete
skull subsequently arrived at the American Museum of Natural History. There was a slight
snag as, when found in New Mexico, it was in lots of little pieces (p.127). Fortunately, a
kindly soul called Granger had lots of glue and plenty of patience, so he put Humpty Taeni
together again.
Size
Most multis were small beasts, but not Taeniolabis taoensis. This skull manages a
length of over fifteen centimetres. As the maximum width is much the same, this was a
broad-headed, sumo-super-heavyweight multi with a short, rounded snout. It' as big as a
beaver. I'd
love to take one out for a walk in the park, but the flatness of the the top of the head
(there's not too much difference in height between the snout and brain box), suggests it'd
be too stupid to understand many commands. If it were expected to fetch a stick, then
Taeniolabis would possibly respond with a vacant stare and a shrug of its
dumbfounded shoulders. Some dogs behave like that as well, but this is because they're
exceptionally clever.
Skull
Normally, for mammals from this time, a decent jaw is a cause for celebration. The specimen
described by Broom is astonishingly good. There was little missing from the head, and I've
risked a couple of inaccurate sketches based loosely on those in the paper.
Taeniolabis in
profile.
Taeniolabis from
on high.
If you look at most mammals, the skull is longer than broad. It's proportionately short in
this case. It's short compared to most multis as well. Especially when seen from the side,
the orbit for the eye is obviously small. The cheek area has
a strong zygomatic arch. The roof of the broad snout is
built by the nasal bones. While being somewhat broader
further back, these are wide along their whole course.
Broom couldn't find an 'extra' bone towards the front termed a
septomaxilla, although he couldn't rule out the
possibility of a small version being present. It's now clear that at least most multis
didn't have such a thing. (It has been reported for a basal
Jurassic multi, but this has been disputed. Others view it as an artefact caused by
damage.) As Broom was particularly interested in comparisons with the egg-laying
monotremes of Australia, perhaps he was hoping for one.
Monotreme jaws have such bones, and he thought multis were probably allies.
The main bone of the upper jaw is the maxilla, and this is
long for a mammal. The rear end provides about 40% of the zygomatic arch. It meets the
parietal at the top of the orbit, and this arrangement bars
the frontal from contributing to the rim of the eye hole
(p.128). This is in contrast to the general situation among living Mammalia. Most extant
mammals also have proportionately larger frontals.
A bone called the jugal often gets involved in constructing the zygomatic arch, but not in
the case of Taeniolabis. It's small and stored away as just the lower rim of the
orbit. (The rear of the jugal was somewhat damaged, and the reconstruction offered involved
a measure of educated guesswork.)
Additional Notes
Some fossils live at the Peabody, Yale. I've heard a further skull may be in the
Smithsonian Museum, Washington DC. |
| References: | Cope (1882), the correct reference will hopefully follow. |
| Osborn & Earle (1895), Fossil mammals of the Puerco beds.
Collection of 1892. Bull. Amer. Mus. Nat. Hist. vii, p.1-70, with 21 figs. |
| Granger & Simpson (1929), A revision of the Tertiary Multituberculata.
Bulletin Amer. Mus. Nat. Hist. 56, p.601-676, 43 figs. |
| Simons NB (1986), Taeniolabis Cope, 1882 (Mammalia, Multituberculata),:
proposed designation of Polymastodon taoensis Cope, 1882 as type species.
Bulletin of Zoological Nomenclature 43(3), p.310-311. |
| Species: | Taeniolabis lamberti Simmons NB, 1987 |
| Place: | Tullock Formation, Montana |
| Country: | USA |
| Age: | Puercan, Paleocene |
| Remarks: | Sumo-heavyweight. |
| Reference: | Simmons (1987), A revision of Taeniolabis (Mammalia:
Multituberculata), with a new species from the Puercan of eastern Montana. J. of Paleont.
61(4), p.794-808. |
| Other reports:
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx |
| Help:
Should anybody have any further information, I'd be pleased to hear of it.
Regarding references and Bibliography:
I haven't and can't verify all the references, so beware. Traditional papers used in
constructing this page are in the bibliography. If you feel these are too few, then send
some more.
With thanks to all the featured sources.
Trevor Dykes, February 2002 Last update: 14.2.2008
ktdykes@arcor.de |
Bibliography:
Broom R (1914), On the structure and affinities of Multituberculata, Bulletin of the
American Museum of Natural History, 33(8), p.115-134.
Clemens WA, Wilson GP & Molnar RE (2003), An enigmatic (Synapsid?) tooth
from the Early Cretaceous of New South Wales, Australia. Journal of Vertebrate
Paleontology, 23 (1), p.232-237.
Eberle JJ (2003), Puercan mammalian systematics and biostratigraphy in the Denver
Formation, Denver Basin, Colorado, Rocky Mountain Geology, 38(1), p.143-169.
Higgins P (2003), A Wyoming succession of Paleocene mammal-bearing localities
bracketing the boundary between the Torrejonian and Tiffanian North American Land Mammal
"Ages", Rocky Mountain Geology, 38 (2), p.247-280.
Kielan-Jaworowska Z & Hurum JH (2001), Phylogeny and systematics of
multituberculate mammals, Palaeontology, Vol 44 (3), p.389-429.
Kielan-Jaworowska Z, Hurum JH & Lopatin AV (2005), Skull structure in
Catopsbaatar and the zygomatic ridges in multituberculate mammals, Acta
Palaeontologica Polonica, 50(3), p.487-512.
Lofgren DL (1995), The Bug Creek Problem and the Cretaceous-Tertiary Transition at
McGuire Creek, Montana, University of California Publications Geological Sciences, vol.
140, 185pp.
Matthew WD, Granger W & Simpson GG, (1928), Paleocene multituberculates from
Mongolia, American Museum Novitates, 331, p.1-4.
McKenna MC & Bell SK, (1997), Classification of Mammals Above the Species Level.
Columbia University Press.
Missiaen, P & Smith T (2008), The Gashatan (late Paleocene) mammmal fauns from
Subeng, Inner Mongolia, China, Acta Palaeontologica Polonica, 53(3), p.357-378.
Scott CS (2003), Late Torrejonian (Middle Paleocene) mammals from South Central
Alberta, Canada. Journal of Paleontology, 77(4), p.745-768.
Scott CR, Fox RC & Youzwyshyn GP (2002), New earliest Tiffanian (late Paleocene)
mammals from Cochrane 2, southwestern Alberta, Canada. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 47
(4), p.691-704.
Simpson GG (1927b), Mammalian fauna and correlation of the Paskapoo Formation of
Alberta, American Museum Novitates, 268, p.1-10.
Weil A (1999), Multituberculate phylogeny and mammalian biogeography in the Late
Cretaceous and earliest Paleocene Western Interior of North America, Ph.D. Dissertation,
University of California, Berkeley, p.1-243.
Weil A (2005), Living large in the Cretaceous, Nature, 433, p.116-117.
Wible JR & Rougier GR (2000), Cranal anatomy of Kryptobaatar dashzevegi
Mammalia, Multituberculata), and its bearing on the evolution of mammalian characters.
Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History, 247, p.1-124. |